Dating the gnostic gospels
The main difference between the two is not the nature or gravity of their sin, but rather their willingness to accept God's mercy.
Peter wept for his sins, came back to Jesus, and was pardoned.
The text could not have been written by eyewitnesses, the way at least two of the canonical Gospels were.
If it wasn't Judas, it would have been someone else. Father Williams: Though the Catholic Church has a canonization process by which it declares certain persons to be in heaven, as saints, it has no such process for declaring people to be condemned.The Gnostics blamed God for the evil in the world and claimed that he created the world in a disordered and flawed way.Thus they champion the rehabilitation of Old Testament figures such as Cain, who killed his brother Abel, and Esau, the elder brother of Jacob, who sold his birthright for a plate of pottage.Father Williams: Remember that Gnosticism arose in the middle of the second century, and the "Gospel of Judas," if authentic, probably dates back to the mid- to late second century.To put a historical perspective on things, that would be like you or me writing a text now on the American Civil War and having that text later used as a primary historical source on the war.